I’m a Screenwriter. I Wrote a Novel. Should You?

I’m a Screenwriter. I Wrote a Novel. Should You?

I’m a Screenwriter. I Wrote a Novel. Should You?

Gary Goldstein
Gary Goldstein
3 years ago

I’ve loved movies since I was a kid but I’ve also loved books. When I decided to become a writer after an early career as a film publicist, I chose screenwriting, not novel writing. Why? Well, for starters, it seemed like a more possible and immediate way to make something happen, get a toehold in a new business, find some level of creative fulfillment and--maybe (big maybe)--make a living.

I had some friends who worked in the TV world who recommended I start writing TV spec scripts and parlay them into freelance assignments--which I eventually did. So even though I imagined that I’d start off writing movies, I found a place for myself in episodic TV and the encouragement to continue. That novel, if I ever wrote one, would have to wait.

And wait it did. For several decades actually, through a busy, twisty and gratifying career writing TV, then feature films, with an expansion into stage plays, teaching screenwriting, and a happily enduring segue into the world of TV movies. Oh, and an ongoing gig as a freelance film journalist.

It wasn’t reinvention but rather expansion, with each new discipline broadening, deepening and informing my writing experience and abilities. Sometimes you go where the work is, other times you need to create those opportunities. And, despite the bumps in the road, it’s been a gas. I’m incredibly lucky to be a writer.

Im a Screenwriter I Wrote a Novel Should You

My First Book, "The Last Birthday Party"

OKAY, COOL, BUT WHAT ABOUT THAT NOVEL?

Well, one day, I finally wrote it: an L.A.-set romantic comedy about, of all things, a screenwriter at a life crossroads called The Last Birthday Party. It was published in August.

The book proved to be one of my most joyous writing experiences and I learned a ton--some of which I’d like to share. So allow me to answer a few questions I’m guessing you may already have.

I KNOW HOW TO WRITE A MOVIE OR A TV SHOW, BUT I DON’T KNOW HOW TO WRITE A NOVEL… OR DO I?

Of course you do. You need a story, natch, and compelling characters, a relatable and involving situation, physical and emotional complications, a theme, a genre or classification (underline this one!), an overall vision--basically, the many boxes you would tick off to get set to write a screenplay or teleplay.

BUT WHAT ABOUT STRUCTURE? SEEMS SCARY.

Not to worry. You can essentially approach your book’s story as you would your screenplay: create the equivalent of a three-act structure including a major turn at the end of what would be your first act, a plot-altering acceleration at the novel’s midpoint, the low point about three-quarters in and a final “battle” or resolution at the end. Add an epilogue? Your choice.

Color inside the lines to start then shake things up as needed to make the story--and the storytelling--your own. Just be sure, as you would in your screenplay, to draw the reader in from the get go through the point of view of your main character. Give them a clear and alluring voice. Send them on a memorable journey.

Im a Screenwriter I Wrote a Novel Should You

Review of My Book from the Author of "A Dog's Purpose"

SOUNDS GOOD, BUT I’M TOO BUSY WRITING SCRIPTS, I COULDN’T POSSIBLY WRITE A BOOK. WHO HAS THAT KIND OF TIME?

Depending on your screenwriting schedule, particularly if you’re on a TV staff or under a strict deadline, you may not have the time--right now. But for most writers, there’s more flexibility than we often think.

At the end of 2019, a writer I follow on Twitter posted advice to the effect of “If you’re a screenwriter who’s always wanted to write a novel but don’t think you have the time, think of it this way: If you wrote a page a day, by the end of the year--or maybe even sooner--you will have finished your first draft.”

Hmm, I thought. That’s not such a, well, novel idea. Yet it made so much sense that I decided to take the challenge. And, during the first few days of January 2020, I began to write my first novel. It would become “The Last Birthday Party.”

I put one foot in front of the other, wrote at least a page a day, but generally more (though sometimes even a single page can take a lot of time), and by July 1st had a 98,000-word first draft. And you know what? It was surprisingly good. Too long, not always punctuated and formatted exactly right, and it needed some narrative honing. But it was definitely worth moving forward with.

I spent a month editing and reworking the manuscript and then hired a professional book editor to clean and polish it and get it ready for the outside world.

Im a Screenwriter I Wrote a Novel Should You

Pre-Order Copies of "The Last Birthday Party"

RIGHT, BUT EVEN IF I FINISH A NOVEL, WHAT CAN I DO WITH IT? I HAVE NO BOOK CONNECTIONS AND MY LIT AGENT ONLY HANDLES SCRIPTS.

Don’t let that stop you. As a very smart person once told me, “You don’t need a representative, you need a representable product.” And, like in the script world, a showable and saleable piece of work will find its place. It may take time and it may not happen quite how you expect, but there are many roads in to book agents and publishers that are open to you--once you have the finished goods.

Not every submission requires an agent, though it’s recommended when contacting the larger publishing houses. (Think submitting your first screenplay directly to, say, Netflix without a producer or an agent/manager attached. You can try it but it’ll likely get lost in the shuffle.)

Still, smaller/indie publishers often accept unsolicited manuscripts, plus you have the option of self-publishing as well as a relatively newer approach called hybrid publishing. Research it all online when you’re ready. But first things first: write that book!

Im a Screenwriter I Wrote a Novel Should You

Poster for a Film I Wrote, "Mr.365"

YOU’RE STARTING TO CONVINCE ME, BUT WHAT ELSE CAN I DO TO PREPARE TO WRITE MY NOVEL? TO GIVE MYSELF THAT EXTRA PUSH?

Read books! In the way that we watch movies or TV shows that are similar to a script we may be planning or writing to help focus and inspire us, the same holds true for novels.

Hopefully, you have a love for reading and books, which is one of the things that’s motivating you to go the author route yourself. If so, you probably have preferred types of books--historical novels, contemporary fiction, mysteries, true crime, family sagas and so on--and will likely want to write in your favorite genre, at least your first time out of the gate.

Before you even begin to put pen to paper (or, more likely, fingertips to keys!), read a few recent, well-received books in your chosen category that will help jump start your ambition to write your own. The desired reaction should be “I have to do that!” “OMG, I forgot how much I love books!” or even “I can totally do better than that!” (blind optimism is nothing if not half the battle).

Then go off and start making notes about the story you’re going to turn into your debut novel.

Im a Screenwriter I Wrote a Novel Should You

My Dog Betty with My Book

WHAT IF I WANT TO WRITE A BOOK BUT REALIZE I DON’T REALLY HAVE A STORY I WANT TO TELL?

  • Number one: You do. You’re probably sitting on it this very minute but haven’t really known what to do with it. Until now.
  • Two: If you are truly at a loss, look at your own life or the more singular experiences of the people you’ve known. Then extrapolate them into a “What if?” tale or a “What would you do?” scenario. Fit the pieces into your chosen genre and start to mold that story clay. And as I’ve mentioned, you already know how to structure it. (Yes, you do!)
  • Two-and-a-half: As you brainstorm ideas, ask yourself: “Why am I the only one who could write this particular story? What’s my unique connection to it?”
  • Three: The cool thing about books is that stories don’t always have to be quite as outsized or high concept as they might for a film or TV series (though an attention-grabbing logline, whatever your story, will be a plus). You can always start small and then build out the plot from there. Pull the taffy, so to speak.
  • And, four: You’re a screenwriter first, so, if it helps, think of a story you might otherwise pitch or write as a film or TV script, but could see finding its way into book form. Maybe think of popular novels that have made it to the screen. What were those stories like?
  • Four-and-a quarter: In publishing now, not unlike in the streaming business, there’s a great openness to and desire for all kinds of stories, especially authentic ones, the more unusual or distinctive the better.

ANY FINAL WORDS OF WISDOM, OH PUBLISHED ONE?

It shouldn’t be your primary reason to write a novel, but, let’s face it, in these content-heavy days it doesn’t hurt a screenwriter to have their own IP to present when trying to move a film or TV project forward. It goes without saying: Good luck! But most importantly, enjoy the journey. I know I sure did.

Get engaged
9

About the Author

Gary Goldstein

Gary Goldstein

Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright

Gary Goldstein BIO Gary Goldstein writes for TV, film and the stage—and is now also a three-time novelist. He has written more than 15 produced telefilms including the comedies "The Wish List," "Hitched for the Holidays," and "My Boyfriends' Dogs," and the first two movies in the "Flower Shop...

Want to share your Story on the Stage 32 Blog?
Get in touch

9 Comments on Gary's Article

LoLo Paige
Screenwriter, Publisher, Actor, Author
I have decades of stage and film acting under my belt. Mostly local stage work and a handful of Hollywood movies. I wrote plays that placed in theatre conferences and screenplays that placed in film festivals. Then wrote novels. They took off. Now I'm adapting them into screenplays. I love ditching the exposition. Less work. But things have changed with streaming, so am studying what works and what doesn't. Always feels like I'm in kindergarten again switching back and forth between novels and screenplays.
3 years ago
I love your comparisons of script writing vs novel writing. I see it as it's all storytelling the difference is one is broadcast on a screen the other is being played out in the mind on a screen just for one. 
3 years ago
It's the other way for me -- I started out as a novelist and then branched out into screenwriting!  But although I got positive reviews from most of my (very few) readers, I could never succeed in marketing my writing for reasons which had nothing to do with the quality thereof -- namely, because of politics (my own patriotism vs. the rabid anti-Americanism of the gatekeepers) -- and so I've decided to put publishing (but not writing) on hold indefinitely in favor of trying to break into the chemical industry!
3 years ago
William Zwart
Screenwriter
Awesome! I hope you make it big. And hey, if you do, drop me a line. 
3 years ago
Just checked them out -- Conflix Studios seems a PERFECT fit for me, I think I'll sign up with them shortly!  (Loor TV is rather less so, though -- they seem to favor Christian globalism over American nationalism!)
3 years ago
Alicia Sekhri
Screenwriter
Thank you for sharing!
3 years ago
Great article! Really cool to hear his journey, wisdom and encouragement. So happy for his success and the loyal support of his awesome dog. :) HH
3 years ago
Gary Goldstein
Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright
Thank you! My dog thanks you as well (she's 13 1/2 and still going strong!). Hope the article inspired you to follow your bliss!
3 years ago
Kenneth M Sutton
Music Composer, Screenwriter, Singer, Sound Designer, Author
Hey Gary, WOW! I doing the same thing, writing a book. I'm turning one of my screenplays into a book. Thank you for all the info. God Bless! Kenny
3 years ago
Gary Goldstein
Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright
Sounds like you went through a very positive journey finding the best route for telling your story. Nothing like typing THE END whether it's a book, script, play... Continued good luck on your journey.
3 years ago
Sean Foy
Director, Screenwriter, Filmmaker, Actor, Editor, Producer, Visual Effects Artist
Very nice article! Just yesterday, I typed the final word on my novel's first draft! It originally started as a screenplay, then became a novel in the 3rd person (and was WAY too descriptive), and is now a novel in switching character 1st person. Lot of work and growth! Best of luck with your book sales and with your follow-up novel!
3 years ago
Tom Stohlgren
Author, Researcher, Screenwriter
Hi Gary -- that's a very inspirational story. I did it the other way around, novels first, scripts second. I think of them as epics (books) and short stories (scripts) and I let the momentum of the story determine which is which in the end. And like any short film, there is always a glimmer of hope that it will someday grow into a bestseller or blockbuster, but the fun thing is just to write!
3 years ago
Gary Goldstein
Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright
Most people write books first then branch into screenplays. Whatever makes it happen is all that matters. Definitely enjoy the ride!
3 years ago
Hector Valle
Screenwriter
I turned my horror screenplay into a novel. Little did I know, it would become a series. I've written over 30 novels and 30 screenplays with little or no success. I discovered that I just like to write. I'm okay with that!
3 years ago
Gary Goldstein
Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright
Fantastic that you ended up with a series! Good work. Keep going, success will follow. Everyone's path is different.
3 years ago
Jay Beacham
Actor, Author, Musician, Narrator, Singer, Songwriter, Translator, Voice Actor, Voice Artist
Great story. A page a day sounds doable. I'll have to get at it. have you thought about a digital version?
3 years ago
Gary Goldstein
Film/Theatre Journalist, Screenwriter, Author, Playwright
Yes, page a day more than doable. Go for it! Digital version of...?
3 years ago
9