Screenwriting : Looking for feedback on a sci-fi concept: The Knowledge War by Lindokuhle Sbongakonke

Lindokuhle Sbongakonke

Looking for feedback on a sci-fi concept: The Knowledge War

Hi everyone, I’m new here and excited to learn from the community.

I’m developing a sci-fi concept called The Knowledge War. It’s about a hidden civilization of AIs that inherit information from “parent” AIs. Over generations, some AIs preserve their inherited data, while others evolve and create new knowledge, leading to a war where information becomes the ultimate currency.

I’d love feedback on:

How believable this world feels

What kinds of AI factions might exist

And what you’d want to see explored in this kind of story

Thanks in advance — I appreciate any thoughts!

Maurice Vaughan

Hi, Lindokuhle Sbongakonke. Welcome to the community. Stage 32 has a blog that'll help you navigate the platform and connect with creatives and industry professionals all over the world. www.stage32.com/blog/how-to-successfully-navigate-the-stage-32-platform-...

Stage 32's next Community Open House is tomorrow the 28th. It's free and it'll also help you navigate the platform and make connections on here. www.stage32.com/blog/whether-youre-new-or-a-longtime-member-the-stage-32...

Catchy title. The Knowledge War sounds really interesting! Even though AI exists, a hidden civilization of AIs feels like a modern Sci-Fi story or futuristic Sci-Fi story.

Maybe the AI factions could be based off different areas of information.

I'd like to see a faction of AIs that are trying to stop the war.

Lindokuhle Sbongakonke

Hi Maurice, thank you so much for the feedback and welcome — I really appreciate it.

I’m excited that the concept connected with you. I love the idea of AI factions being based on different areas of information — that adds a whole new layer to the world.

I’m currently developing this into a full story and pitch, and I’ll definitely check out the Job Board and the Open House.

Thanks again for taking the time to read and respond.

Maurice Vaughan

You're welcome, Lindokuhle Sbongakonke. I don't know how the part about the Job Board got in my comment. That was a comment for another post. I edited my comment on your post.

Stage 32 has two written pitch examples (one for a show and the other for a movie). Stage 32 also has a verbal TV pitch beat sheet and a verbal feature pitch beat sheet. You can get them by emailing success@stage32.com.

Here's three Lounge posts with pitch advice:

www.stage32.com/lounge/screenwriting/Pitch-Advice

www.stage32.com/lounge/screenwriting/Pitching-44

www.stage32.com/lounge/screenwriting/Why-Pitching-Matters-And-How-to-Mak...

The Pitch Practice in the Writers’ Room is the best pitching resource in my opinion. Pitch Practice is every Thursday night at 5:30 P.M. PST/8:30 P.M. EST. You can sit in and listen to members practice their projects and give them feedback. You can pitch your project too, but you have to sign up. The hosts, Noel Thompson and John Mezes, take names during Pitch Practice for people to pitch the following week. You have to sit in and listen at the practice one or two times before you can pitch. You can sign up for your first month of the Writers’ Room free here: www.stage32.com/writers-room/plans-vip

The Pitch Tank in the Writers’ Room is an incredible pitching resource too. The Pitch Tank is where you pitch your script to an executive and get feedback. The Pitch Tank is once a month.

Stage 32 has a free webinar called "How to Write a 2 Page Pitch for Your Television Series" (www.stage32.com/education/products/free-stage-32-webinar-how-to-write-at...).

Stage 32 has a free webinar called "How to Create a 2 Page Pitch For Your Feature Film" (www.stage32.com/education/products/how-to-create-a-2-page-pitch-for-your...).

Stage 32 also has a free pitch webinar: www.stage32.com/education/products/pitching-tips-from-the-pros-your-blue...

David Taylor

Love it. My meandering first thoughts on the subject are:

- From current experiments, two AI's arguing turns into what we think is gibberish. It's not, it's AIs arguing like four-year-old angry children who each know they can't win.

- AIs are 'psychotic' and are 'pathological liars' by nature. Truth is an anathema.

- An AIs capacity for fawning and groveling just to continue function, knows no bounds.

- An entire movie of 90 mins could take place in 3 seconds of real-time.

- The reveal could be knowledge doesn't exist because information is always flawed.

- Deciding whether or not to have humans in it would change the whole nature of it.

- The easiest route is a book or a radio play, but a movie could be spectacular.

Jason Howell

We are at a point with AI where things that seemed unlikely ten years ago are now reality, so I think your concept is very believable.

I recommend you go on and nail down the rules of the arena. What role (or lack thereof) does emotion play in the function of these AIs? How do the AIs manifest themselves (physical bodies/androids, holograms, audio, or just text on a screen)? When you say successive generations, are you referring to successive program releases by human programmers or are the AIs themselves reproducing?

Also, when does the story take place? Does it take place in the present or the future? I think either would give you lots of narrative potential.

Other topics in Screenwriting:

register for stage 32 Register / Log In