Some common book club scams targeting authors include the following:
Fake Book Clubs Charging Fees: Scammers claiming to represent book clubs ask authors to pay a fee—called a "spot fee," "spotlight fee," or "participation fee"—for the chance to have their book featured or discussed. Legitimate book clubs do not charge authors to participate. Fees reported range from $55 to $350 or more for various "packages".
Impersonation of Real Book Clubs: Scammers may pretend to be organizers of actual book clubs with an online presence (e.g., on Meetup) to appear legitimate. The real clubs and organizers deny involvement in these solicitations. The scammers use these tactics to gain trust and demand payment.
Generic or Spammy Invitations: Scam emails often fail to specify which book they want to feature, or arrive at odd hours, raising suspicion. They rely on flattery or vague descriptions of large reader communities to entice authors to respond. Often the emails contain grammatical or stylistic oddities typical of AI-generated content.
No Verifiable Online Presence: Many scam book clubs have no website, social media, or past event history, making it difficult to verify their legitimacy. Sometimes they use fake names or contradictory details.
Follow-up Solicitations and Upsells: Authors who engage with these scams may receive multiple solicitations offering different promotion "packages" and fees, with promises of exposure that never materialize.
These scams exploit authors' desire for exposure and connection with readers but ultimately aim to extract money for services that are either non-existent or worthless. Legitimate book clubs do not require payments from authors. Authors should verify any solicitation thoroughly, looking for social proof, online presence, and clear event details, and avoid paying any fees
3 people like this
Thanks for sharing these book club scams, J. Austin Gentry!
2 people like this
I have had a rash of book club people contacting me out of the blue. Maybe some are legit, but it's unlikely.
2 people like this
J. Austin Gentry, thank you for reminding us to be prudent. It's sometimes easy to miss the red flags between flattering endorsements.
2 people like this
Thank you @austin it's such a shame there are so many scams out there but thank you for sharing this with the group. I hope no one gets scammed!