I've done this too little: rewriting my scripts. It's always so hard to change your first ideas, because you love your initial inspirations. (Do others have that 'problem' as well?) But of course, it's about 'kill your darlings'.
Nevertheless I have to confess: I'm enjoying revising my script 'Myths' and maybe I can finish it for the 'Search for new Bood'-contest.....
3 people like this
Absolutely, I think many writers struggle with letting go of their first ideas. Sometimes the hardest part of rewriting is knowing which “darlings” are worth keeping and which ones are holding the story back. It’s great that you’re enjoying revising Myths good luck with the contest.
2 people like this
I definitely think that’s one of the hardest parts of writing you’ve lived with those first ideas for so long that even when you know something needs to change, it can be difficult to let it go. It’s great that you’re actually enjoying the revision of Myths though. What’s been the biggest change you’ve made to the script so far?
2 people like this
Rewriting really is where the actual magic happens, even if cutting those initial ideas hurts. A good mental trick I use is keeping a 'Scrapbook' or 'Cut Ideas' doc—that way, you aren't deleting your darlings forever, just saving them for another story. It makes it much easier to let go of what isn't serving the current script!
1 person likes this
Evelyn Carter The most intense part so far was to change some perspectives and dialogues on the first two pages. I shifted some perspectives on characters and changed some dialogues in a more natural way (I hope).
2 people like this
So true Ayomide Abiodun. I keep two versions!
1 person likes this
First screenplay for me so I expected revisions.z?x6zsr ?
2 people like this
Sorry Frank. I got cut off. Enjoy rewriting because there's more great writing inside for you to uncover.
3 people like this
I can’t stand rewriting either. Once I finish a script I’m like it’s time to move on, but I know that it is not. I think the best way to do. It is to do a first draft do another first draft on another project and then return to the first one. Look for the bones of the script. Cut out the fat. Your second pass will be much better.
1 person likes this
Frank van der Meijden Yeah, those first two pages can be surprisingly difficult because they’re doing so much work to establish the characters and the tone. I think changing the perspectives and making the dialogue feel more natural can really change how the audience connects with the characters right away. Did you find that changing those pages also affected how you wanted to write the characters in the scenes that come after?
3 people like this
I've come to love the Rewriting part because it allows me to improve and expand on what I've already written.
2 people like this
Brendan Tedford I completely get that. Rewriting can be where the story really starts to take shape because you already know the characters and direction, so you can focus more on making everything work better. Do you usually discover new things about your characters while rewriting, or do you mostly use the process to strengthen what you already had in mind?
2 people like this
Evelyn Carter I actually do discover new things about my characters while rewriting or sometimes, I'll find a better direction for a scene. Usually, the first draft for me is just getting the story on the page then after I see the shape, the rewrite gives me the room to ask what each moment feels like, what each character brings to it, and what needs to happen between the big beats.
2 people like this
That's a common struggle, and the reason it's hard to kill your darlings is that those ideas are what made you fall in love with the story. What's the one darling you're most nervous about cutting from Myths, and could you keep its spirit in another form?
2 people like this
I don't enjoy the process Frank van der Meijden but I am always (to date) more satisfied with the resulting draft after having gone through the effort. It takes a lot of organic motivation sometimes to get moving on that task, haha.
2 people like this
It’s definitely difficult to change your original concepts, however you also have to let the story guide you to where it wants to go even if it isn’t what you first expected to come out of your first idea! It’s an interesting and fulfilling process!! Enjoy it :)
2 people like this
You're not alone. Rewrites are the work. As the saying goes, writing is editing. Sounds like you're finding some real momentum with Myths. Excited to see where this draft takes you.
2 people like this
Frank Meijden That attachment to first ideas is nearly universal, the version that arrives first often carries the excitement that got you writing in the first place, so cutting or changing it can feel like losing the reason you started. "Kill your darlings" gets thrown around so casually that it's easy to forget how genuinely hard it is in practice, especially when the darling in question was the seed of the whole project.
Good sign that you're actually enjoying the revision process on "Myths" though, that's often the tell that the rewrite is working, not fighting the material, but discovering what it actually wants to be once you're not precious about the first draft anymore. Hope it comes together in time for the Search for New Blood deadline, sounds like real momentum.
1 person likes this
Evelyn Carter I discovered that certain 'secondary characters' needed more attention. I realized that if they were introduced in a way that was 'too superficial,' there was no point in including them in the script at all.
1 person likes this
Samantha Rivera I'm still processing one big change. I'ld like to start this story in the dark. That's quite unusual, because in film we want 'to see something'. I don't know if I dare to start this story in 'blackness', with only sounds around us, maybe for 50 seconds. (Of course it's relevant for the character I'm introducing).
2 people like this
Great to hear you're enjoying the re-writing process. Sometimes a lot of effort goes into making the first draft "perfect", but this is very rarely the case. The first draft is like tipping all the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle out of the box and onto the table - all the ideas are now out of your head and on the page, so the next step is to sift through them and make a complete, coherent picture for you to refine.
3 people like this
I typically find that my darlings are good for a fling and bad for a long-term relationship :)
They might inspire me at the outset, and that’s great, but I usually have to break up with them.
3 people like this
I think mythic storytelling especially benefits from being revisited from a lot of different angles. The danger isn’t only whether the story works for us personally, but whether the mythology is legible to someone who doesn’t already live inside our heads. Sometimes the thing we love most is carrying private meaning rather than story meaning, and rewriting is where you start finding the difference. That doesn’t always mean killing the darling, either. Sometimes it just means discovering what job it was actually supposed to be doing.
3 people like this
I think it can be incredibly hard to let go of the things that first made you fall in love with a script, even when you know a rewrite may ultimately make it much stronger. I’ve definitely seen projects where the hardest note for the writer to take was also the one that ended up opening the story up in a really exciting way. I just went through this on a project that I'm producing; once the co-writers finally embraced my big overarching structural note and really internalized it and implemented it fully, the entire script felt transformed in a great way. Themes that were buried under the surface came to light, and it started feeling like a real movie.
The fact that you’re actually enjoying revising your script feels like a great sign, though. There’s something really satisfying about getting enough distance from the first version that you start discovering things you couldn’t see before. I hope you get it finished in time for the contest!
2 people like this
Frank, Ewan's jigsaw image is the right one. The thing I keep relearning is that a darling is often not wrong, just in the wrong place. The last note I got on a pilot was that a reader could not follow the cause behind my opening set piece. The fix was not cutting what I loved, it was making the connection visible sooner. So before you kill one, try moving it. And on opening in darkness, I would dare it. Fifty seconds of sound can be a real hook if the first image answers the question the dark just asked.
2 people like this
I try to view rewrites like cutting and shining a raw gemstone. I'm not killing my darlings, I'm shaping the facets of something amazing.
or that's the theory anyway.
2 people like this
Do you also have investors that are willing to invest in the Project if they like it?
1 person likes this
Elena Schumann I don't have investors yet, Elena. I hope to find some possibilities through contests.
2 people like this
After one of my scripts was shopped, I did what was mostly an edit pass, but had some rewriting, but then was handed a new outline and a rewrite contract. I guess I was lucky to get that outline since it really helped with what was a page 1 rewrite. I learned a lot with that experience. The rewriting grew on me and I really love how how new draft turned out.
5 people like this
Something I like to do is keep a little darling graveyard which is just a folder on my desktop full of little darlings that I have culled from past projects, I have found that often they can be used somewhere else, so you're not really killing them just relocating them for a little while. This can help with the knee-jerk reaction to removing ideas that you love because you can tell yourself you're saving them for later, but after a while I've also found myself amused at some of the little darlings I found particularly hard to part with and realized that maybe with some distance and reflection they weren't as fantastic as initially thought.
2 people like this
I love that approach Alexandra Hensley
2 people like this
I have grown to enjoy re-writing because the end product is so much better when I'm done.
3 people like this
Every rewriting is writing. Remember that!!!
3 people like this
I find writing out the plot progression beforehand (sequentially) minimises rewrites.
2 people like this
Stefano Pavone, you are absolutely right! I can't believe writing without the plot figured out in advance. I was taught you start from the last shot of the last scene, and then work backwards in order to figure out how your characters get there.
3 people like this
Brendan Kelly I agree 1,000% - like Memento. Oh wait! That final scene came first.
2 people like this
Yeah, it's hard when you go back to reread everything you wrote the first time, something might've been too extreme or too light, it's about having a balance of a proper story, sometimes doing it again is the best move when it stays in your mind for a while, especially if something about the story feels off after you go back to reread it again.
3 people like this
I love hearing about the different approaches Brendan Kelly . I just today discovered the final scene for my ebook series and I am almost 180K words into a 300K Five ebook series and would have never figured out this ending without writing the story and letting it evolve at it's pace and demands.
2 people like this
Hi Frank
I believe rewriting is not just an unavoidable part of screenwriting — it's an essential part of the craft.
In fact, I think real mastery begins when you become capable of consciously letting go of something you once considered brilliant because you discover a better, more interesting, or more cinematic solution. It's not about sacrificing your ideas; it's about serving the story rather than your attachment to those ideas.
That's one of the reasons I often say that a screenplay is not simply a text. It's a process. A screenwriter doesn't just create the idea, plot, and characters. They also have to preserve the integrity of the story throughout the entire production process.
Sometimes changes become necessary even during filming or post-production. I remember a film production in Moscow where, during the dubbing stage, a character's line had to be completely changed to fit footage that had already been shot. The screenwriter had to find a new line that worked with what the audience could see on screen while keeping the story coherent.
That's screenwriting, too.
So I wouldn't see rewriting as something opposed to the original creative impulse. It's how that impulse develops into a stronger, more complete story.
1 person likes this
Ernest Hemingway said "The only kind of writing is rewriting"
1 person likes this
Hello, fellow creatives! I'm so thrilled to share with you that my stage play, "Divorce Towne", has been published by Next Stage Press! It's a comedy that involves confessions, revelations and lots of vodka... You can check it out here: https://www.nextstagepress.com/divorce-towne/
1 person likes this
Everett Ruth (slurs words) FLABJEWLUS! I'm not as think as you drunk I am -- Riley Green https://youtu.be/5SCJM6aYsK0