Screenwriting : Idol - Screenplay feedback by Shayla Booth

Shayla Booth

Idol - Screenplay feedback

Can I have feedback for this scene? I have tried to describe characters, settings, it's my second screenplay and I want it to be good before I pitch. This is the logline: 'When Grace moves to a small town, the locals become dangerously obsessed with her, and she must uncover why she's the target of their fixation in order to escape before their obsession turns deadly.'

For context this is a prologue to the story:

EXT. MILLER HOUSE - NIGHT

A two-story colonial sits at the end of a tree-lined street in what should be a picture-perfect small town. White picket fence. Manicured lawn. American flag hanging limp in the suffocating stillness.

But tonight, it's under siege.

DOZENS OF TOWNSPEOPLE swarm the property like insects drawn to rotting meat. They press against windows, their breath fogging the glass in rhythmic patterns in, out, in, out, perfectly synchronized. They rattle doorknobs with mechanical precision. They climb onto the wraparound porch, moving on all fours, stepping over flower pots and trampling Claire's prized begonias into pulp.

Their faces are illuminated by the warm glow from inside the house. Some are CRYING. Tears streaming down their faces while they SMILE. Others have eyes rolled back, showing only whites. A WOMAN in blood-spattered pyjamas claws at a window screen. She doesn't stop. Her exposed nail beds leave dark smears on the glass. She's LAUGHING.

The crowd moves as one organism, pulsing, breathing, reaching. When one person inhales, they all inhale. The sound is deafening.

INT. MILLER HOUSE - LIVING ROOM - CONTINUOUS

The coffee table is overturned, family photos scattered across the floor, their glass frames cracked, the images beneath staring up accusingly. Furniture has been shoved haphazardly against doors, the antique credenza, the leather armchair David's father left him, even the piano bench. Everything.

Windows rattle in their frames like teeth chattering. The whole house GROANS like something alive and dying.

DAVID MILLER (40s, high school history teacher, wire-rim glasses cracked and hanging off one ear, button-down shirt soaked with sweat and something darker) drags a heavy oak bookshelf across the hardwood floor. His hands are bleeding. The bookshelf leaves a dark smear behind it.

Books tumble off the shelves- Gibbon's Decline and Fall, Team of Rivals, a battered copy of To Kill a Mockingbird. They land with wet, heavy thuds.

DAVID

(voice cracking, almost gone from shouting)

Kitchen! Claire—check the kitchen door!

CLAIRE MILLER (40s, ER nurse, still in her blood-stained scrubs from the hospital, dark hair matted to her skull, a deep gash bleeding freely from her temple down her neck) sprints past him. Her sneakers leave red footprints on the hardwood. She's running on something beyond adrenaline now. Beyond fear. Pure survival instinct.

CLAIRE

It's locked! Deadbolt! Chain! They're at the back door!

Her voice breaks into a sob.

A CRASH. Multiple HANDS smash through the living room window simultaneously, sending a explosion of glass across the Persian rug. The hands grope blindly, fingers splayed, searching, caressing the air.

One hand belongs to MRS. CHEN—Sarah's piano teacher. Her fingers are broken, bent at impossible angles. She's still wearing her wedding ring. The skin around it has split.

David grabs the aluminium baseball bat—Ethan's, from Little League and swings hard. CRACK. CRACK. CRACK. Bones break. The hands don't withdraw. They keep reaching, even as fingers dangle uselessly.

SARAH MILLER (16, their daughter, long dark hair tangled and stuck to her face with sweat, eyes wild and red-rimmed, wearing an oversized hoodie torn at the shoulder) stands frozen halfway up the staircase. She clutches her younger brother against her side so tightly he can barely breathe.

SARAH

(voice breaking, barely audible)

Dad—dad, what did we do? What did we DO?

From outside, a CHANT begins. Low at first, almost melodic, a lullaby sung by a hundred voices. Then building, building, building—

TOWNSPEOPLE (O.S.)

(overlapping, frantic, ecstatic)

Sarah-David-Claire-Ethan... The Millers-The Millers-The Millers... The family-our family-THE FAMILY...

The voices fracture into glossolalia, speaking in tongues, animal sounds mixed with names.

David's face goes corpse-white. He looks at Claire. Her eyes are hollow. They both understand now.

This is about all of them. The entire family. Together. As one.

CLAIRE

(whispered, horrified)

They want to keep us.

Sarah can't move. She's transfixed by the windows where faces press against the glass like specimens pinned to boards. Faces she knows. Faces she trusted.

At one window: MR. HAYES, who runs the hardware store, his face pressed so hard against the glass that blood vessels burst in his eyes. He's mouthing something over and over. His teeth scrape the glass.

At another: PRINCIPAL MORRISON, mascara running down her face in black rivers, hands splayed against the pane. At the side window: JESSICA WONG, Sarah's best friend since third grade, still in her soccer uniform. She's sobbing hysterically, her face contorted.

James LO

very well written, Shay!

I’m an unpublished noob but from what I’ve read about screenwriting, the pros will probably say your descriptions are too novelistic and descriptive.

but personally i found they really put me in the scene, especially since it’s an action scene with scant dialog.

keep it up! horror’s not my bag but your writing hooked me. happy zombies—who woulda thunk?

Shayla Booth

Hi James LO thankyou, I am originally an author who has turned to screen-writing, so I'll probably over describe haha. Thankyou though :)

Maurice Vaughan

Incredible, terrifying scene, Shayla Booth! I like how the scene starts calm, then turns into chaos! The scene pulled me in and kept my attention. Fantastic job on the action lines! This is really impressive for a second script! If I was a producer, executive, manager, etc., I'd request the whole script after reading this.

Marie Hatten

Shayla Booth I’m also a noob but this absolutely hooked me , it’s very visual . Well done .

Jon Shallit

Good! Trade scripts? an ADD?

Michael Fitzer, MFA

Compelling! The most difficult thing for prose writers to do is omit needless words. Your script reads beautifully, but there’s a lot of extra. To be fair, the initial script should be treated as a sales tool and this sort of writing hooks some executives because it’s enjoyable to read while others find it cumbersome to get through and they just want the basics. So in the end you need to do what you’re most comfortable with and lean into it. I do recommend going through and scrutinizing every single if, and, but, and looking to see if you are saying the same thing twice at any point throughout the piece. You may consider it to be reinforcing information, but some readers may view it as just telling them the same thing more than once. Good luck! keep us posted!

David Taylor

It's great. Obviously needs formatting and abridging, and dialogue sorted. Readers do not want to see huge blocks of text, - it suggests problems - they like white-space balance. One assumes it flashbacks, and we see all those nice people like the Hardware Store guy, the Principal, and the Best Friend, in the lead up to what happened. The idea definitely has legs.

Shayla Booth

Hi Michael Fitzer, MFA Thankyou so much, I am actually a novel writer so I think my habit is adding loads of description, but I will try to improve this! David Taylor Hi David, thankyou for this. I will take note of your advice :)

Kseniia Zhuravleva

Hi Shayla Booth , this looks really good. I like that you have strong pacing in the action.

Shayla Booth

Hi! Kseniia Zhuravleva thankyou so much :)

Other topics in Screenwriting:

register for stage 32 Register / Log In