Producing : What Makes a Producer Take a First-Time TV Creator Seriously? by Ke’Andre Hawthorne

Ke’Andre Hawthorne

What Makes a Producer Take a First-Time TV Creator Seriously?

I’m a first-year screenwriter developing a serialized one-hour crime drama, and one thing I’ve been learning quickly is that having the story is only one part of getting a series into the right hands.

In my case, the pilot is complete, all 10 episodes of Season 1 are fully written, and Seasons 2 and 3 are structurally developed from beginning through the endgame — including the major character arcs, conflicts, turning points, reveals, losses, callbacks, and final resolution.

For producers who work in scripted television: when you’re introduced to a first-time creator with that level of development already completed, what makes you take the creator and project seriously beyond the script itself?

Is it mainly the strength of the pilot? The creator’s voice and connection to the material? A clear series engine? The pitch package? Knowing the long-term story? Or something else?

I’m interested in understanding how producers evaluate that from the other side of the table.

Jack Vincent

I'm not experienced in pitching series, Ke’Andre Hawthorne, but from film and from what I know about series, you'll want a short, punchy pitch dossier that takes their breath away immediately, with a focus on the key characters and what makes them irresistible, and a killer pilot episode.

Most producers won't consider even looking at the remaining episodes until the pilot knocks them out. Having the entire season written is not a negative; it's a positive. But you really have to crush it with your pitch and pilot.

Good luck...

Yakub Deyemi

Congratulations on getting that far with the project, Ke’Andre. Having the pilot completed while already having Seasons 2 and 3 structurally mapped out shows a serious level of commitment and long-term thinking.

From a screenplay perspective, I think the pilot has to do more than simply introduce the story. It needs to clearly demonstrate the series engine, establish compelling characters, create a strong reason to continue watching, and give producers confidence that the concept can sustain multiple episodes and seasons.

The pitch package and presentation also matter because they help communicate the larger vision beyond the pilot itself.

I work with screenplays through writing, proofreading, and professional formatting, so I always see the value in making sure the material is not only strong creatively but also polished and professionally presented.

I'd be interested to hear how the pilot currently presents the larger series vision.

Ke’Andre Hawthorne

Yakub Deyemi Appreciate that, Yakub. That’s actually one of the main things I designed the pilot around.

The pilot opens with an older, emotionally exhausted Jayson in a dangerous situation, then takes us back to him at 17 before the life has really changed him. So the audience immediately knows where he eventually ends up, but not how this kid becomes that man.

From there, the pilot establishes the family pressure driving him — his mother’s declining health, financial instability, his responsibility toward his younger brother Donnie — along with his friendship with Manny and the neighborhood environment surrounding them. It also begins planting the criminal and law-enforcement worlds that will grow much larger as the series develops.

The series engine is really the consequences of each choice widening the world around Jayson. What starts as two teenagers trying to solve an immediate money problem gradually becomes a larger story about family, brotherhood, power, loyalty and what happens when the life built to protect the people you love becomes the thing that destroys them.

Season 1 is fully written, and Seasons 2 and 3 are structurally developed from beginning through the endgame, so a number of details planted in the pilot are designed to gain new meaning later in the series and on rewatch.

The pitch package carries the broader three-season vision, while I wanted the pilot itself to make the audience ask one central question:

What happened to this kid?

Ke’Andre Hawthorne

jJack Vincent Thank you, Jack. That’s something I’ve been learning quickly — the amount of material behind the series only matters if the pilot and pitch make someone want to see more first. I’ve been putting a lot of focus into making sure those two pieces communicate the characters, emotional hook and series engine without trying to explain everything at once. I appreciate the advice.

Zoltán Varga

I’d add one thing, Ke’Andre: being prepared is important, but so is being easy to work with. A producer may love the pilot, but they’re also asking themselves whether this is someone they can develop a series with for the next few years. Being open to notes without losing your own voice can matter just as much as having three seasons mapped out.

Ke’Andre Hawthorne

Absolutely Zoltán Varga . That balance is important to me — protecting the identity of the series while still being open to strong notes and collaboration. Television is too collaborative to approach it any other way.

Abhijeet Aade

Ke’Andre Hawthorne From my perspective, the amount of development is useful, but I don't think it’s what makes a first-time creator credible by itself. A producer ultimately has to believe both the project works and the creator has a distinctive voice worth betting on.

I’d probably put the strongest pilot first. If the pilot immediately demonstrates the characters, tone, conflict, and series engine, then knowing that the creator has thought through Seasons 2 and 3 becomes reassuring rather than essential.

I also think the creator’s connection to the material matters. Why you had to tell this particular story can sometimes be more persuasive than another ten pages of mythology or future-season planning.

The long-term architecture is valuable too, especially for a serialized crime drama, but I’d treat it as evidence that you understand where the story is going—not as the main selling point.

If I were approaching producers, my hierarchy would probably be: strong pilot → distinctive voice → compelling series engine → clear pitch materials → evidence that the larger story has somewhere meaningful to go.

I’d be curious to hear from producers: what is the first thing you look for that makes you think, “I want to meet this creator”?

Other topics in Producing:

register for stage 32 Register / Log In