Let's talk about one of the hardest choices a writer faces: does a dark story deserve a dark ending?
I believe a tragic ending is often more powerful. Here's why.
There's a hard truth about human nature: we love watching the hero fall. As the Green Goblin once said:
"The city found you entertaining for a while. But the one thing people love more than a hero... is to see a hero fail, fall, die trying."
We love happy endings. But bad endings stay with us.
Examples:
Squid Game
Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad
These endings didn't just satisfy—they buried themselves in our minds. They carried weight. They said something.
A happy ending does the opposite. The hero wins, the audience is satisfied—but by tomorrow, you've forgotten the film. The message fades. The ending becomes formulaic.
Of course, there's a trade-off: bad endings can hurt your score. Audiences sometimes punish a film for not giving them what they wanted.
But here's my question: is a story that people remember worth more than a story they rated 9/10 and forgot?
So what do you think—bad ending or happy ending? And when is each one the right choice?
3 people like this
I think this changes with the current world situation. Now that things seem pretty dire everywhere, people may be looking for more happy endings. After all, we all want to enterain ourselves and forget how awful the world is. Who knows, maybe we will prefer sad endings when the real world is better? Who knows.
2 people like this
Very interesting question I'll be thinking about all week Kyle Morin . On one hand, certain endings were made possible by the times (see CHINATOWN and how what was going on in the world allowed for a down-ending that was not the norm for that genre). A movie (and ending) that I absolutely love and consider perfect cinema. However a friend who watched it recently was telling me how they didn't like the ending because of the injustice. That said, this person is not the best barometer for story and always wants bad people to get theirs. Still they are 1 audience member with their opinion.
On the other hand I can't imagine my favorite film TRUE ROMANCE having the sad ending that Tarantino wrote, but Tony Scott changed. Yet as I watched the new remastered version of STATE OF GRACE this weekend, I can't imagine it ending happy (Director Phil Joanou explains in the special features what they shot as an alt...yuck. He made the right choice).
I think endings with irony... positive & negative work the best if the writer is talented enough to achieve it, and it makes sense for the characters & story.
Ian Milne your right mr lan milne
but i prefer tragdic or grey ending
for example shinjuku incident movie for me the ending was tragdic and effectful
grey ending in my opinion is one of the best things you can have a ending that is not bad or not good
grey ending have balance you know
1 person likes this
Julio Torres this is your opinion and i respect it it is very great thing and i agree with you
but sometimes we prefer correct ending ending should be fit with that story
you know?